Pre-Sentencing Mitigation Evaluations
Objective psychological evaluations that give Indiana sentencing courts clear, well-supported information about the person before the court.
When a person is about to be sentenced, the court is asked to weigh not only the offense but the person who committed it. A pre-sentencing mitigation evaluation gives the court reliable, clinically grounded information about that person: their mental health, cognitive functioning, developmental history, and the factors that bear on treatment needs and supervision.
Dr. David Lombard, PhD, is a licensed Indiana psychologist with more than 30 years of clinical and forensic experience. He conducts pre-sentencing psychological evaluations for adults and youthful defendants, including in capital cases. The evaluation is objective, and its findings are reported as they are found.
What a Mitigation Evaluation Addresses
Indiana law permits a sentencing court to consider mitigating circumstances in deciding what sentence to impose and whether to suspend a sentence in favor of probation (IC 35-38-1-7.1(b)). Among the listed circumstances are post-traumatic stress disorder, traumatic brain injury, and post-concussive brain injury. Indiana appellate courts have also long recognized that a defendant's mental illness may carry mitigating weight, depending on its severity, its duration, its effect on the person's functioning and self-control, and its connection to the offense.
Depending on the referral question, an evaluation may address:
Psychiatric diagnoses and their history, severity, and course.
Intellectual and cognitive functioning, including learning and developmental disabilities.
Neurocognitive concerns, including traumatic brain injury and post-concussive symptoms.
Trauma history and post-traumatic stress, including combat-related trauma in veterans.
Substance use and its relationship to the person's mental health.
Developmental and maturity factors for youthful defendants.
The relationship, if any, between these factors and the conduct at issue.
Treatment needs, treatment history, and amenability to treatment.
Risk and protective factors relevant to probation, community corrections, or specialized court programs.
Capital Cases
When the State seeks a sentence of death or life imprisonment without parole, Indiana law requires the sentencing authority to weigh mitigating circumstances, including whether the defendant was under the influence of extreme mental or emotional disturbance and whether the defendant's capacity to appreciate the criminality of the conduct or to conform it to the law was substantially impaired by mental disease or defect (IC 35-50-2-9).
Capital mitigation evaluations follow the same objective methods described below, with a more extensive review of the person's life history, including developmental, family, educational, medical, and psychiatric records across the lifespan. Dr. Lombard can work alongside the defense team's mitigation specialist while keeping his role as an independent evaluator distinct from the team's advocacy.
How Referrals Are Made
Most mitigation evaluations are requested by defense counsel. Evaluations may also be ordered by the court as part of the presentence process (IC 35-38-1-10) or requested by the prosecution or jointly by the parties. The referral question is defined in writing at the outset so that the scope of the evaluation is clear to everyone involved.
A mitigation evaluation is separate from the presentence investigation report prepared by the probation department (IC 35-38-1-8 and 35-38-1-9). It is intended to supplement that report with specialized psychological findings, not to replace it.
The Evaluation Process
Referral and scope. The referring attorney or court identifies the questions to be addressed, the sentencing date, and the available records.
Records review. Relevant records may include charging documents, the presentence report, prior evaluations, and medical, mental health, school, military, employment, and jail records.
Notice of purpose. The person being evaluated is informed of the purpose of the evaluation, who requested it, who will receive the report, and the limits of confidentiality.
Clinical interviews. Interviews cover personal, family, developmental, educational, medical, psychiatric, and substance use history.
Psychological testing, where indicated. Standardized measures may assess cognitive functioning, personality and psychopathology, trauma symptoms, and response validity.
Collateral contacts. With appropriate authorization, family members, treatment providers, and others with relevant knowledge may be interviewed.
Written report. The report describes the methods used, the findings, and the opinions reached, with the limits of those opinions stated plainly.
Testimony. Dr. Lombard is available to testify at sentencing hearings.
Interviews can be conducted at the office or at county jails when transport is impractical.
Standards and Neutrality
Evaluations follow the APA Ethical Principles of Psychologists and Code of Conduct and the APA Specialty Guidelines for Forensic Psychology. Dr. Lombard's role is that of an evaluator, not an advocate. Opinions are based on the data, and findings that do not support mitigation are reported with the same care as findings that do. No particular conclusion or sentencing outcome is promised.
Dr. Lombard does not provide treatment to anyone he evaluates and does not evaluate former patients. He does not accept a retained mitigation referral in a case in which he previously served as the court-appointed competency or sanity evaluator.
For Defense Counsel, Prosecutors, and the Court
Turnaround: 2 to 3 weeks from receipt of the referral, records, and retainer. Capital cases and cases with extensive records may require additional time. Please contact the office early when a sentencing date is set.
Fees: $3,000 retainer, billed at $300 per hour against the retainer.
Service area: All Indiana counties, with a focus on northeast Indiana.
Referrals: Call (260) 459-2900 or use the Contact page. Please do not send identifying case information through the website form.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who receives the report?
The report is provided to the party who requested the evaluation. When defense counsel retains the evaluation, counsel decides whether and how to present it to the court. Court-ordered evaluations are provided to the court.
Will the evaluation support a reduced sentence?
Not necessarily. The evaluation is objective, and its findings are reported as they are found. What weight to give any mitigating circumstance is for the court to decide.
How is this different from the presentence investigation report?
The presentence report is prepared by a probation officer and covers the offense, criminal history, and social background. A mitigation evaluation adds a licensed psychologist's assessment of mental health, cognitive, and developmental factors using clinical interviews and standardized testing.
Do you accept capital cases?
Yes. Capital mitigation evaluations are available for cases in which the State seeks death or life imprisonment without parole. Please contact the office as early as possible, since these evaluations involve a more extensive records review.
Can the evaluation be done if the defendant is in custody?
Yes. Interviews and testing can be completed at the county jail.
Are veterans' service-related conditions considered?
Yes. Indiana's sentencing statute specifically lists post-traumatic stress disorder, traumatic brain injury, and post-concussive brain injury among the circumstances a court may consider. Military and VA records are reviewed when available.
How far in advance should an evaluation be requested?
As early as possible, ideally when a plea is entered or a trial concludes, so that records can be gathered and the report completed before the sentencing hearing.
References
Indiana Code 35-38-1, Entry of Judgment and Sentencing, including sections 7.1 (considerations in imposing sentence), 8 and 9 (presentence investigation and report), and 10 (physical or mental examination).
Indiana Code 35-50-2-9, Death sentence and life imprisonment without parole.
Weeks v. State, 697 N.E.2d 28 (Ind. 1998).
American Psychological Association. (2013). Specialty Guidelines for Forensic Psychology. American Psychologist, 68(1), 7-19.