Fitness-for-Duty Evaluations
Objective psychological evaluations that help employers and public safety agencies decide whether an employee can safely perform the job
When an employee's behavior raises a genuine question about whether they can do their job safely, an employer needs an answer that is objective, defensible, and limited to what the job requires. A psychological fitness-for-duty evaluation provides that answer.
Dr. David Lombard, PhD, is a licensed Indiana psychologist with more than 30 years of clinical and forensic experience. He conducts fitness-for-duty evaluations for public safety agencies, healthcare systems, school corporations, universities, and private employers. The evaluation is independent, and its findings are reported as they are found.
When a Fitness-for-Duty Evaluation Is Appropriate
Under the Americans with Disabilities Act, an employer may require a current employee to undergo a medical or psychological examination only when the examination is job-related and consistent with business necessity (EEOC Enforcement Guidance). In practice, that usually means the employer has a reasonable, objective basis to believe a psychological condition may be affecting the employee's ability to perform essential job functions or may pose a safety risk.
Common reasons for referral include:
Observed changes in performance, judgment, or conduct that suggest a possible psychological cause.
Threatening, erratic, or unusually volatile behavior at work.
Return to work after a psychiatric hospitalization or an extended leave for a mental health condition.
A critical incident, such as an officer-involved shooting, when agency policy calls for an evaluation.
Concerns involving employees in safety-sensitive positions.
A fitness-for-duty evaluation is not a substitute for ordinary performance management or discipline. Employers are encouraged to consult employment counsel before requiring one.
Public Safety Agencies
Evaluations of police officers, firefighters, corrections staff, and dispatchers follow the Psychological Fitness-for-Duty Evaluation Guidelines of the International Association of Chiefs of Police (IACP) Police Psychological Services Section. Consistent with those guidelines, the agency is the client, the referral questions are defined in writing, and the report is limited to the information the agency needs to make an employment decision.
What the Evaluation Addresses
Depending on the referral, the evaluation may address:
Whether the employee has a psychological condition, and if so, its nature and severity.
Whether the condition impairs the employee's ability to perform the essential functions of the job safely and effectively.
Whether the employee is fit for duty, fit with conditions or reasonable accommodations, temporarily unfit, or unfit.
When temporarily unfit, the treatment or steps that may restore fitness and a suggested time frame for reevaluation.
Recommendations for return-to-work conditions, monitoring, or follow-up evaluation.
The Evaluation Process
Referral and scope. The employer provides a written referral describing the specific concerns, the employee's job description, and the questions to be answered.
Records review. Relevant records may include performance and personnel records, incident reports, and, with authorization, treatment records.
Notice to the employee. The employee is informed of the purpose of the evaluation, who requested it, who will receive the report, and the limits of confidentiality.
Clinical interview. The interview covers work history, the events that led to the referral, and relevant personal, medical, and psychiatric history.
Psychological testing. Standardized measures assess personality, psychopathology, and response style.
Collateral information. When appropriate, supervisors or others with direct knowledge of the concerns may be interviewed.
Written report. The report answers the referral questions and states the basis and limits of each opinion.
Consultation and testimony. Dr. Lombard is available to discuss the findings with the employer and to testify if needed.
Standards and Independence
Evaluations follow the APA Ethical Principles of Psychologists and Code of Conduct, the APA Specialty Guidelines for Forensic Psychology, and, for public safety agencies, the IACP fitness-for-duty guidelines. Dr. Lombard does not provide treatment to anyone he evaluates and does not evaluate former patients. Findings are reported as they are found, and no particular outcome is promised to either the employer or the employee.
For Employers and Agencies
Turnaround: Examinations are usually scheduled promptly, and reports are typically completed within 1 to 2 weeks of the examination.
Fees: $300 per hour. Depositions and court testimony are billed at $450 per hour.
Service area: All Indiana counties, with a focus on northeast Indiana.
Referrals: Call (260) 459-2900 or use the Contact page. Please do not send identifying employee information through the website form.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can an employer require an employee to attend a fitness-for-duty evaluation?
Generally, yes, when the examination is job-related and consistent with business necessity under the ADA. Because the answer depends on the facts and the employer's policies, employers should consult employment counsel before making a referral.
Who receives the report?
The employer that requested the evaluation receives the report. The employee is told this before the evaluation begins. Access to the report by the employee is governed by law, policy, and any applicable agreements.
Will the report include the employee's full history and diagnosis?
The report includes the information needed to answer the referral questions. Personal details that do not bear on fitness for duty are kept out of the report whenever possible.
Does the evaluation decide whether the employee keeps their job?
No. The evaluation provides an opinion about the employee's psychological fitness to perform the job. Employment decisions remain with the employer.
Will you provide treatment if the employee needs it?
No. To preserve independence, Dr. Lombard does not treat anyone he evaluates. The report may recommend treatment with another provider.
References
U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. Enforcement Guidance on Disability-Related Inquiries and Medical Examinations of Employees under the ADA. EEOC
International Association of Chiefs of Police, Police Psychological Services Section. Psychological Fitness-for-Duty Evaluation Guidelines. IACP
American Psychological Association. (2013). Specialty Guidelines for Forensic Psychology. American Psychologist, 68(1), 7-19. APA